Welcome to East of Chicago, a charming pizza haven nestled in Sugarcreek, Ohio. Located at 149 Dover Rd NW, this eatery is not just a place to grab a bite; it's an experience that celebrates the art of pizza-making. Whether you’re indulging in a classic Chicago Melt or exploring the unique Cheeseburger Pizza, every dish bursts with flavor and quality ingredients.

As a food reviewer, I find it refreshing to discover a place that combines excellent food with equally outstanding service. Visitors can expect friendly staff who go above and beyond to ensure a warm dining experience. Just take it from customers like Lisa Meier and T Sheets, who rave about the attention they've received, indicating that East of Chicago is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a community hub where you’re treated like family.

The menu offers an impressive variety, from their large pizzas, which include the hearty Deluxe Pizza loaded with toppings to satisfy any appetite, to a selection of 12” and 6” subs that cater to diverse tastes. Each item is crafted with fresh ingredients, from spicy steak subs to savory meatball subs, all available at reasonable prices—just $9.99 for the 12” options!

For those who appreciate a buffet-style experience, East of Chicago serves seriously tempting options. Customers can curate their ideal plates, diving into an assortment of fresh salads and delicious pizzas. Katie Watkins highlights the rich flavor of the pizza and the delightful salad bar, proving that this establishment aims to please all palates.

As I reflect on my experiences at East of Chicago, one thing stands out: the emphasis on quality. The dishes are consistently praised for their freshness and taste, making each visit a delightful culinary adventure. Each bite feels as if it has been prepared with love, ensuring that satisfaction is not just expected, but guaranteed. It's no surprise that returning patrons, like Hainee Dyrcz, leave with nothing but praise, dubbing their experience “heavenly good.”

Overall, East of Chicago is a delightful destination for anyone in search of great pizza, astonishing subs, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. With each visit, you’ll feel the care put into every dish, making it a must-try for both locals and visitors alike. So, whether you're looking to share a meal with friends or just craving a delicious slice, East of Chicago promises an unforgettable dining experience!